Value Accounting
Value Accounting
- Version
- 2.5 · effective November 20, 2026
- Cite
- valuecreationprotocol.com/value-accounting/reference
What to know first. Value Accounting is the discipline of accounting for the value you create the way money is accounted for: naming it, measuring it, and keeping an honest book of it. The book is made of Value Entries, one per moment, and each one is "Not a claim you make; a fact they confirm." An entry moves through five stages, Expected, Witnessed, Shown, Confirmed and Settled: states an entry is in, never targets. Money is one thing the value leaves behind, counted later.
Purpose
This document establishes the official, canonical definitions for Value Accounting as a framework: what it is, the five stages an entry moves through (an expectation first, then the four stages of a recorded moment of value), what each stage means, and what Value Accounting is not. It also carries how a newcomer starts a book of their own.
When in doubt, check this document.
What is Value Accounting?
The discipline of accounting for the value you create the way money is accounted for: naming it, measuring it, and keeping an honest book of it. It is not traditional accounting — there is no quarterly report to shareholders and no bending the numbers to look good. Value is the first thing you count; money is one Value Wake it leaves behind, counted later.
A Value Wake is "the real, lagging consequence a realized value leaves trailing behind it — in whatever kind it takes."
What the book is made of
One entry per moment. A Value Entry is "One recorded moment where value actually landed for someone — witnessed, cited to when and where it happened, and confirmed by the person who received it. The atomic unit of the value ledger. Not a claim you make; a fact they confirm." The book itself is the Value Ledger: "The honest book of value that actually reached people — read backward to see what happened, never a score to climb or a leaderboard to win. A filled-in number that does not correspond to value a real person received is worse than an empty one."
When value compounds. A compounding moment is "any later moment where value someone already received deepens or grows: they understand it again, they can now do something further with it, or someone else can, from their own side. Understanding it again is a dated line on the entry that holds it, counted once with it; anything further is its own Value Entry, confirmed by its own receiver, that Builds On the entry it grew out of."
Whose word counts, and where money sits
Whose say it is. Value is "the real change in what someone can do, and only the person who received it can say it happened". Value Realized, "Value that has actually landed for a person and been accepted by them", is "the beholder's to grant, never the creator's to declare".
Two lanes, never added. Value received outside the team and value received inside it are counted on two parallel lines, and the inside line "never sums into this number". The rule behind it: "figures are tied back to each other (reconciled) but incommensurable things are never added together". Incommensurable things share no common measure.
Money beside the book. "Money is one wake; so is a capability that keeps paying off, or a relationship that deepens. Like a boat's wake, it is genuine and it trails: recorded last, never first, and never the thing you steer by." The order is named Realize Value First: "value should land — be witnessed, shown, and confirmed by the person it served — before the money follows".
Five states an entry can be in
A Value Entry moves through five stages, Expected, Witnessed, Shown, Confirmed and Settled.
The Value Accounting handbook, published on valuefirstbooks.com, teaches this practice one move at a time, and its words are quoted throughout. It explains the last stage: "Once a month, run one pass over the book. Take the moments people have confirmed, put each one in the month the value landed, and close them. That is what the last stage, Settled, means."
The Five Stages: Official Definitions
The stages are outcome-states, never targets. Chris Carolan, founder of the Value-First Team, ratified them in these words: "anti-funnel — stages are outcome-states a witnessed moment IS IN, never targets to advance toward." An entry that sits at Witnessed for a long time is "information about where value stands, read backward, never a velocity number to beat".
Where the handbook says a stage in plainer words, its words stand beside the stage's line.
1. Expected
Line: Someone wrote down what one person or one team is expected to receive, before it happens.
Canon terms it carries: CARE Record, which holds the intention behind it.
2. Witnessed
Line: Somebody saw the value land and wrote it down.
Canon terms it carries: Value Witnessing, "Recording value by pointing to the moment it actually happened — witnessed, timestamped, cited — rather than asserting value without pointing to where it landed. The citation is the thing a nice-sounding claim cannot fake."; Value Entry.
3. Shown
Line: What was written has been put in front of the person it's about.
Why it is there: Chris, 2026-09-06: "Shown needs to count. The biggest reason for never leaving the Witnessed stage is that the value is never communicated effectively."
Canon terms it carries: Value Visibility, "showing someone the value they received is often what completes it — visibility is not the report you file afterward, it is part of how the value becomes real."
4. Confirmed
Line: The person who received it says it landed, or, for value received inside the team, the hand our rules name. Never the person who did the work.
The hand our rules name: for value received inside the team, the receiver's own word or the leader linked above them.
Canon terms it carries: Value Realized; Beholder-Confirmed Value.
5. Settled
Line: The month is closed.
In the handbook's words: "The month it belongs to has been closed. Money never decides it."
Canon terms it carries: Read Backward, Never a Forward Target; Reconcile, Never Sum; The One Reconciled Realized Number.
Quick Reference Card
VALUE ACCOUNTING — keeping an honest book of the value you create
One entry per moment. The receiver's word confirms it. Money is one Value Wake, counted later.
THE FIVE STAGES (outcome-states, never targets)
Expected — someone wrote down what one person or one team
is expected to receive, before it happens
Witnessed — somebody saw the value land and wrote it down
Shown — what was written has been put in front of
the person it's about
Confirmed — the person who received it says it landed, or,
for value received inside the team, the hand
our rules name; never the person who did the work
Settled — the month is closed; money never decides it
TWO LANES — outside and inside, read side by side, never added
MONEY — beside the entry; never moves a stage
THE MONTH — read backward: information, never a target
Usage Rules
The stages
- Use the five stage words exactly — Expected, Witnessed, Shown, Confirmed, Settled — in that order.
- Disputed and not shown are verdicts, not stages. A disputed entry "does not advance; it stays at Shown", and a not-shown entry stays at Witnessed.
What earns a row
- The four inclusion conditions, ratified 2026-08-24 ("Ratify 1-4"): "Discrete; realized for a named recipient distinct from the doer; evidenced by a real citable moment; moves the initiative on the maturity axis."
- Creation is open; confirmation is the gate. "The four conditions are the test an entry must pass to be confirmed, not a permission slip it needs to be written."
- A count is never an entry. One moment is one row.
Who confirms
- The doer never confirms. "BOTH HANDS ARE VALID, THE DOER NEVER IS" — for value received inside the team, the receiver's own word or the leader linked above them (Chris, 2026-09-06). Chris never confirms an entry in the outside lane. The receiver's own words count wherever they are found: "counterparty's own words cited to a real timestamped moment count as their confirmation whoever found them; an agent's own say-so with no counterparty language behind it stays banned".
- An open entry stays open. Chris, 2026-08-09: "If it stays open, it stays open. It should only come out of the queue if we get confirmation that it did or did not add value."
The month
- Two lanes, never added.
- Money never moves a stage.
- The month's number is information. "The number is information, never a target, and never a leaderboard." and "A quiet month is information too".
What Value Accounting is not
- Not traditional accounting. "there is no quarterly report to shareholders and no bending the numbers to look good".
- Not money. Money is one Value Wake, recorded last; it never decides Settled.
- Not a funnel, and not a set of targets. The stages are states an entry is in.
- Not a score, a leaderboard or a target. The Value Ledger is "never a score to climb or a leaderboard to win".
- Not a record of work done. "an entry posts when value is realized for a beneficiary, not when work is done". Creating a row on agreed work claims nothing until the receiver's word confirms it.
- Not the doer's claim. "Not a claim you make; a fact they confirm."
Value Accounting and CARE
Chris, 2026-11-13, accepting CARE: "Return on Intention and measuring value (records) in service of care (records) will end up being a critical part of the Value Accounting foundation, correct?" CARE is not a replacement for Value Accounting: "CARE offers a way to tend its intention and how people experience it; it is not a replacement for the Value Practice or Value Accounting concepts." See the CARE document.
- Expected value lives on the Value Entry. Chris, 2026-11-13: "Expected value needs to live on the value entry." Later the same day he made Expected the first stage, before Witnessed. "Awaiting confirmation is not an expectation state.", so an entry waiting for its confirming word at Witnessed is never relabelled Expected.
- Key Value Indicators fit inside Value Accounting. Chris, 2026-11-13: "the concept of KVIs needs to fit within our overall framing of Value Accounting."
Start your own book of value
The Value Accounting handbook: "You don't need software to start, and you don't need anyone's permission." Chris Carolan, founder of the Value-First Team, on where to begin: "Open one view."
Open one view, in the place you already keep track of the people you work with.
The handbook: "If that's a customer system, it's a view in that system. If the only place you keep track of people is a notebook, it's a page in that notebook. Don't buy anything to start."
Give it four columns. The handbook:
- "the moment of value, dated and specific;"
- "who received it;"
- "who did the work;"
- "their own words, when you have them."
The handbook: "That's the whole view."
Find one moment from this week.
The handbook, quoting Chris: "Every time you finish something, before you mark it done, ask the actual question: who received the value, and have they said anything about it yet? If they have, write down what they said. If they haven't, leave the row open and go ask."
The easiest first row is a moment where someone has already told you, in their own words, that something changed for them: a message, an email, a note, something said on a call you recorded. Start there if you have one. If you don't, take something you finished this week and ask the question above.
Write one row for that one moment. You don't need to be sure it counts before you write it.
"Creation is open; confirmation is the gate."
- The moment: what happened, specifically, and the date it happened, not the date you wrote it down. The handbook: "Dated by the real moment, never by the administrative one."
- Who received it: the person, by name.
- Who did the work: usually you. It is never the person who received it. "realized for a named recipient distinct from the doer"
- Their own words: copy their sentence exactly, and note where and when they said it: the date of the message, or the point in the recording.
If you don't have their words, leave that column empty. Don't fill it with yours.
Chris, 2026-08-09: "If it stays open, it stays open." The handbook: "An open row is the book telling the truth."
You have written a first entry when one row names one moment, the person who received it and the person who did the work, and its last column holds their words or is honestly empty.
The handbook: "The first time that column holds a receiver's words, you have a book of value. Until then you have a list of what you did, with a column waiting."
What keeps it honest
One moment is one row
"A count is never an entry. One moment is one row."
The handbook: "Twenty episodes is not twenty people who received something." "The same moment seen from two places is one row. Two different things received in one conversation are two rows. One thing said by two different people is two rows, because each names their own receiver."
The person who did the work never confirms it
However sure you are that it helped, your word doesn't confirm it. Theirs does.
Their word, not yours
"not our claim that we delivered it, but their statement that they got it."
Copy their sentence exactly. Don't tidy it, and don't sum up what you think they meant.
The handbook: "A cleaned-up quote is a fabrication, not a tidy quote." "A thank-you on its own is politeness. A thank-you that says what changed is a moment." "It's the easiest column to fill with yours, and the one that makes the book worthless when you do."
Words, not a number
Write what changed in words. Don't turn it into hours or dollars.
"never forced into dollars, never summed across kinds"
Money beside the book
Keep money out of the four columns. If money changes hands, note it beside the row, afterwards. The money never decides whether value landed.
What a first one looks like when it is done well
Read your row back. A good first entry:
- names one moment, with the date it happened, specific enough that the person would recognize it as theirs;
- names the person who received it, and a different person who did the work;
- carries their sentence, word for word, with where and when they said it, or leaves that column empty and the row open;
- has no dollar figure, no hours saved and no score in it;
- says nothing about what they gained that they have not said themselves.
The handbook: "The person a row names recognizes the moment as theirs." "Not your summary of what they meant. Not your sense that they were pleased. Their sentence, about something that changed for them, at a moment you can point to."
Where to go next
The handbook goes on from here:
- Chapter 1, the view you just opened.
- Chapter 3, what a row needs, and how to write down what you expect someone to receive before it happens.
- Chapter 6, hearing it in the conversations you already have.
- Chapter 8, getting their word.
When in doubt, check this document.
Value-First Team — Connect. Magnify. Multiply.
Protocol home
VCP is originated and canonically implemented by Value-First Team. Anyone may read, cite, and operate the protocol independently of firm engagement.